Re: Do people need help with proposal writing? -Reply Lisa F. Richman Ballance 24 Apr 1998 08:57 EST
Aren't there 2 issues here? Professional Ethics of a writer vs. accountability of an organization? As a person who often writes grants, I am bound to my professional ethics and could be liable IF the following remain unbeknownst to the institution and are intentional (i.e.): plagerism: taking language from previously public works (including speeches) intentional misrepresentation of facts: making up data (such as literature citations) conflict of interest: writing a grant for 2 different organizations to the same funding agency, AND having a bias for 1 that can be proven (such as being on the board or being a employable by the grant, if funded) IF the institution that I am writing the grant for KNOWS about the above and WILLINGLY (signs off) approves the proposal for submission (and this can be proven, by signature or otherwise) then I would be "OFF THE HOOK, EH" (grin here)... Lisa Ballance At 08:08 AM 4/24/98 -0400, you wrote: >Interesting issue. When I write a proposal with or for someone else, they at >least buy into the ideas and procedures which are going into the proposal--more >often, a group (including me) will invent the details and I simply write them >down in the most persuasive manner. But, in any case, when it leaves campus >over the signature of the PI, it is his/her responsibility. He/she gets the >credit, he/she gets to run the project when it's funded. > >But legally, it's a proposal submitted by the institution and the institution >gets whatever accrues as a result--dollars, responsibility to perform as >promised, credit for a wonderful job, blame if it's botched, and legal >liability if somebody really screws up. > >When a corporation issues a report--Arthur Anderson, for instance, or a CPA >firm, or an environmental consultant--it comes from the corporation. One >person may present it to the client, but all credit/blame falls on the >corporation as an entity. The individual who actually put the thing together >is never an issue, except perhaps internally in the corporation. Seems to me >that proposal-writing is similar. When I write proposals for non-profits as a >consultant, which I occasionally do, the proposal is submitted by and owned by >the non-profit, the identity of the actual author is immaterial. > >Has anyone ever heard of a case where a proposal written by someone other than >the PI has led to a charge of misconduct, as Terry suggested might happen? > >Bill Campbell >Director, Grants & Research >University of Wisconsin-River Falls > > _____________________________________________ Lisa R. Ballance, Director Corporate and Foundation Relations 101 Maryland Hall University of Richmond University of Richmond, VA 23173 (804) 289-8445 (804) 289-8943 xxxxxx@richmond.edu http://www.richmond.edu