Re: Follow-up on Group/Discussion Forum Robert Beattie 14 Feb 2006 11:51 EST
One flaw in an otherwise good plan for a group is that it may be vulnerable to "spamming." Thus it is necessary for the moderator to screen the first 1 or 2 messages someone posts. Is this like a Yahoo group? I belong to a couple of Yahoo groups and find them very useful. There was, however, a rash of unrelated messages being posted until the moderators took to screening first postings. These groups started small with known members and then increased in size, slowly. Thus this screening option was easily done. I do not know how this would work with such a large already existing group. Can you batch load the current members with an invitation to join. Once all the original members of the listsev are in, then new joiners are reviewed for first posting? Is this a problem for Google Groups? Bob xxxxxx@umich.edu On Feb 14, 2006, at 11:24 AM, Mauneel Desai wrote: After suggesting about the Google group last week, I got many responses and most of them were positive. Some people were worried about a few things and I will try to clear it out in this e-mail. 1. Google Group doesn’t take away the option of e-mail from people who would still prefer e-mail. You can always select the option of receiving e-mails so that whenever someone posts a response/question, you can receive an e-mail. 2. Google also lets you receive e-mail alerts based on keywords. For example, if certain staff members are interested in receiving any e- mails that discusses Federal Demonstration Partnership, they can choose to do so and for other messages, they can visit the group. 3. The best part is that a group will reduce a lot of duplicate e- mails. For example rather then sending an e-mail for the same question that has been discussed several times in the past, they can search the group and get a response to their question. As time goes by, there will be several common questions which would already have been answered several times. 4. Another great advantage is that when new members join, the can easily go and search through the groups and they would have the same access to the information as other members who joined several months ago. Currently, if new people subscribe to a listserv, they don’t have any access or knowledge of the valuable information that was discussed in the past on the listserv. They only gain knowledge about what would be discussed after they subscribe to the listserv. Again, this leads to several duplicate e-mails. It is much easier to search for the information within the group (powered by Google search). Please let me know if you still have questions. If everyone agrees to, we can move to a Google group rather then having a listserv. -- Mauneel D Desai Research Specialist, Information Systems Project Coordinator, RiSC Team Leader Office of Vice Chancellor for Research University of Illinois @ Chicago Ph: (312) 413 - 7713 ====================================================================== I nstructions on how to use the RESADM-L Mailing List, including subscription information and a web-searchable archive, are available via our web site at http://www.hrinet.org (click on "Listserv Lists") ====================================================================== ====================================================================== Instructions on how to use the RESADM-L Mailing List, including subscription information and a web-searchable archive, are available via our web site at http://www.hrinet.org (click on "Listserv Lists") ======================================================================