Re: Grants.gov soon to become MANDATORY? Robert Beattie 09 Mar 2005 17:24 EST
I think that the system was to be available for funding agencies to use as they saw fit. Do note that time passes quickly; it has been over a year since Grants.gov was implemented, in November, 2003. By now there have been some 1500 submissions through the system. Moreover, my impression from recent Department of Energy guidelines is that both Grants.gov and IIPS were an option. The requirement for use will be agency driven. We have done some other agency applications where G.g was mandatory. My first step was to buy a PC for our grants office( that has 50 Macs). I have not had problems recently with the Pure Edge option. In the summer of 2004, we did have problems with the large NIH Director's Pioneer awards but did end up submitting ok. I have been speaking out against the lack of platform options since the system was first announced as PC only, in summer of 2003. Strange, isn't it that the feds take Microsoft to court as a monopoly and then require us to use a windows platform? I think there are no plans (never were any plans) to add more platforms. My estimate of local Mac usage is that 30% of our faculty use them. Most of the UM administrative units got rid of them in order to use PeopleSoft. The G.g solution for large institutions is their System to System (S2S) versions that links the electronic proposal management system of a university to the G.g system. This became live in January. Of course, you need to have your local system ready to link :) There is a good presentation about the plans for S2S at the FDP website http://thefdp.org/Meeting_May2004.html There is more recent information at http://www.grants.gov/DoingBusinessApplicant I think we have a couple of options for dealing with G.g: continue to complain about the lack of flexibility with Pure Edge, ask sponsors to not require G.g, and begin to plan for S2S. I think there are vendors who will soon offer solutions for the latter as a short term solution for those who cannot deal with Pure Edge. It might be cheaper to buy a PC. The Grants.gov staff have heard the Mac complaints for 2 years and not acted on them. Why should we expect a change. I do not want each agency to continue to use its own system, no matter how Mac friendly they might be. That is the biggest nightmare of all. Bob (personal aside to Rich -- perhaps we can talk about this at the forthcoming MI-SRA meeting) __________________________________ Robert Beattie Managing Senior Project Representative for Electronic Research Administration Division of Research Development and Administration University of Michigan 3003 S. State Street Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1274 office: 734 936-1283 mobile: 734 717-6281 xxxxxx@umich.edu On Mar 9, 2005, at 4:46 PM, Richard Magyar wrote: Hi, Has anyone come across a submission in which using the new grants.gov process was MANDATORY? My understanding was that the grants.gov system would be phased in gradually, with only voluntary participation for at least the next year or so. Imagine my surprise when we found out that our latest DOE grant REQUIRES the grants.gov submission mechanism. The problem, for us, is in the software grants.gov requires us to use. The “PureEdge” viewer is incompatible with Macintoshes, and the company developing that software (PureEdge Solutions) has no plans to ever create a Mac solution. They recommend using VirtualPC, which is awkward and unreliable workaround. I’d originally hoped that grants.gov would mature as a service in the next year or so, and eventually expand it’s support to multiple platforms. "Fastlane" is a good example of exactly that kind of success through graduate service roll-out. But if we are all to be required to use this new service more-or-less immediately, then waiting for the bugs to be worked out will NOT be an option. Anyone else in the same boat? Anyone have any insight on grants.gov or solutions to these platform issues? -- Thanks for your time, Rich Magyar Systems Administrator Eastern Michigan University Graduate Studies & Research 734-487-3090 xxxxxx@emich.edu ====================================================================== Instructions on how to use the RESADM-L Mailing List, including subscription information and a web-searchable archive, are available via our web site at http://www.hrinet.org (click on "Listserv Lists") ====================================================================== ====================================================================== Instructions on how to use the RESADM-L Mailing List, including subscription information and a web-searchable archive, are available via our web site at http://www.hrinet.org (click on "Listserv Lists") ======================================================================